Vermont House Debate on Iraq
Here is the text of the message I contributed to the 2-13-07 Debate in the Vermont House on resolution HR 11 calling for an immediate and orderly withdrawal of US troops from Iraq;
"Madame Speaker,
I thank the member from Newport City for his perspective on history and would add to that the words of George Santayana, that "without a sense of history we are doomed to repeat our mistakes".
I would also add that the town I represent ,Putney ,has a great sense of history as well, and our greatest legacy, Sen.George Aiken faced a similar situation almost 40 years ago, when the Vietnam conflict was being debated.
At the time, Sen. Aiken, advised the president to ,
"Declare Victory and Get Out !"
That advice would be well taken again today.
This resolution today is supportive of our troops ,contrary to those who say otherwise.
This resolution allows us to exercise our due diligence and question leadership when our leaders are misguiding us and taking us astray.
This resolution , which I support, doesn't question our troops in Iraq, but it questions the president and his misguided policy in Iraq.
I will vote yes on this resolution and urge my colleagues to also support this resolution so the voices of Vermonters can be heard.
2007 End of Session Report
Greetings ! I’m glad to be back home from the 2007 legislative session. I’m enjoying the work and the great people to work with- and now I’m sure enjoying being back home, full time.
There are an amazing number of good hearted, hard-working people in the legislature. We work well together, to keep up with each concern and committee, so our votes are well informed.
Thanks to the Windham County delegation for being so welcoming and generous with their time, showing me the ropes around the statehouse and the legislative process. We’re expected to carry a full load, right away-by leadership and constituents-as well it should be. Their able tutelage has made my first session productive and predictable. I’m especially grateful to district-mate, David Deen for sharing his 10 terms of experience. David’s the “Deen of the House”-especially when it comes to rules and procedures-and his weekly class on this has been a great help to myself and all the freshmen.
I appreciate my assignments to House Human Services, The Sexual Harassment Complaint Committee, Chair of the Windham County Caucus and most recently to Vt.Supreme Court Justice Paul Reiber’s Task Force on Mental Illness/Co-Occurring Disorders in Corrections.
I feel we got a LOT of good work done at the statehouse. These are some of the highlights. It’s an honor to serve you and if you’d like more details-or you’d like us to pay more attention to something, feel free to contact me- until then, take care, - Mike
Climate change and
Economic Opportunity
The climate change bill passed by the legislature will save money for Vermont businesses and homeowners and create jobs. It invests in renewable technologies for Vermont businesses that will help turn Vermont into a center of economic growth. In the process, it helps reduce our greenhouse gas emissions.
To fund the bill’s all-fuels energy efficiency, the legislature would end the special treatment Vermont Yankee receives when paying property taxes. Currently, the owner of Vermont Yankee, a conglomerate based in Louisiana called Entergy, has been singled out for special treatment when paying property taxes. Last year, Entergy paid a half million dollars less in property taxes than it did five years ago. Wouldn’t you like to be paying less in property taxes than you were 5 years ago? That’s one reason your taxes are higher-you’re subsidizing a Louisiana company’s tax bill. We don’t think that’s fair and want to correct a mistake. This bill asks Entergy to pay their fair share, but still maintains a preferential property tax rate for Vermont Yankee. Entergy would be treated the same as other electric generators, like wind.
This bill will ensure that Vermonters, not just Entergy, will save money. By expanding that work to include all fuels, not just electricity, this bill will put money in the pockets of Vermonters. It will create an estimated 200 jobs in Vermont’s growing renewable energy industry. And it will take an important step towards a more secure and affordable energy future for Vermont. That future is critical to a vibrant economy.
Update. Unfortunately, the governor disagreed with us, vetoed H.520 and the veto stood. We will revisit both issues next year, and we’re confident we’ll pass legislation that is fair and provides for a cleaner, greener future.
Protecting Our Water
Vermont faces several challenges in protecting our water: adequate funding for the Fish and Wildlife Department, safe groundwater, phosphorous pollution in Lake Champlain and protection of our rivers from stormwater.
Lake Champlain continues to be polluted by excessive amounts of phosphorous. The legislature
-continued on next page-
Protecting Water -continued
addressed this problem through two pieces of legislation-a ban on dishwasher detergents that
contain phosphorous and we called on the Agency of Natural Resources to reopen the watershed clean up plan known as the Lake Champlain TMDL. Legislation also passed, that gave the state universal jurisdiction over all, in ground , septic
systems and potable water supplies. This will ensure all systems are built to the highest standards to prevent unintended runoff. The new law allows for increased flexibility for the use of - innovative in-ground systems to meet the challenges of hard –to- perk land.
The legislature also provided money to ANR through the budget, to begin the process of mapping our most precious resource, our groundwater that 60% of Vermonters rely on for their drinking water.
Lastly the legislature passed a bill that contains several imaginative ideas for increasing funding for the Fish and Wildlife Department. This bill will be the focus of public input between now and the next session of the legislature, with the hope that the legislature will pass a bill next year. The problem here is that license sales, the historic funding source for the Fish and Wildlife Department, have been declining nation wide and here in Vermont. More broad-based funding is needed if we are to have a strong Fish and Wildlife Department.-from. Rep. David Deen –Chair-Committee on Fish, Wildlife and Water Resources
Affordable Health Care for All
Catamount Health is the compromise plan worked out last year to bridge the gap between the governor’s insistence on reform coming from within the current structure and the Democratic push for a single payer-universal plan.
We’re moving forward with Catamount BUT, we’re also planning to implement a universal , single payer plan in 2012 if it doesn’t meet the desired outcomes.
What that means is we’re building a new structure for health care coverage in Vermont. It will address the concerns of inclusiveness, quality and cost control.
What we’ve done so far is pour the foundation and start the first floor of this new structure. Then, we’ll continue adding more floors until everyone is covered. If that happens with existing insurance companies, fine. If not, we have Plan B waiting to step in.
Phase One of implementation starts in October.
This will allow those who have been without any health insurance for the past 12 months to sign up and avail themselves of health care coverage.
Catamount Health will provide a comprehensive set of health services, with the premium depending on income. To find out if you qualify go to www.hcr.vt.gov or call 1-800-250-8427.
Next session the legislature will turn more attention to how to make insurance more affordable for those who currently have insurance but are paying too much.
Prescription Drugs S.115, An Act Relating to Increasing Transparency in Prescription Drug Pricing and Information, directly addresses the fastest rising health care spending sector, prescription drugs. On average, each Vermonter spends $1,000 on prescriptions annually, of which 38% is out-of-pocket.
S.115 regulates Pharmacy Benefit Managers, drug marketing, prescription drug data mining, and will lower prescription drug costs. It includes a Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Fee that raises over half a million dollars to fund its cost containment provisions. These include: academic detailing, generic status notification, and a Generic Sample Pilot Program. All told, the opportunities for savings are in the tens of millions of dollars. Transparency, consumer protection, cost containment, prescriber privacy, and evidence-based prescribing are the guiding principles of S.115. This bill is another important step in overall health care reform.
We’re concerned about the high cost of everything, from gas prices that remain at historic highs to rising costs in everything else from housing to healthcare. These are the same costs that are driving up the cost of education/property taxes.
We’re committed to maintain the high quality education our schools currently provide and look at a more fair way paying for our schools.
In this session we looked at some of the immediate and long term ways we can address school costs.
The task was made more difficult by the fact that we expect more of our schools today and many of the cost drivers, such as health care, special education, and energy costs are not easily controlled at a local level. In addition to the cost containment measures contained in the education spending bill, other provisions included in the bill are: maintaining high spending thresholds at 125% of average per pupil spending; look at both high and low spending special education districts and helping high spending districts identify alternatives; reducing the homestead adjustment from $10,000 to $8,000; and reducing the homestead property tax from $1.10 to $0.87 for 2008 only.
There will be a number of studies before the session begins in January, including: a study of the reasons schools exceed the excess spending threshold and a recommendation for criteria for exempting school districts from the consequences of exceeding the threshold; a study of the effects of cost drivers on education spending; and a requirement for the Commissioner of Education to submit a report to the house and senate committees on education that describes insights on governance derived from recent statewide forums.
Pre-K Bill Passes- We also passed an innovative and landmark bill to provide more pre-K opportunities for Vermont children and improve school readiness. (See my website for details)
Campaign Finance Reform
When Vermont enacted its comprehensive campaign finance law in 1997, the legislature compiled an extensive record documenting the influence of money in Vermont politics, exploring issues that go to the heart of democracy. Act 64, Vermont Campaign Finance Law, was adopted out of concern over the escalating arms race in campaign fundraising and spending that undermined public confidence in government. Candidates and elected officials were required to spend more time and attention on fundraising instead of listening and better serving their constituents. However, the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Vermont’s campaign finance laws meant the legislature needed to act to reestablish some limits on contribution amounts.
Contribution limits promote accountability and public trust and encourage candidates to reach out to a broad base of supporters. Contribution limits promote public confidence that elected individuals will be accountable to voters rather than to wealthy donors. Only three states do not have contribution limits. Many states limit aggregate amounts of contributions during a given time period. An interesting point to note, only once, in the Vermont case from last year, has the Supreme Court invalidated contribution limits. Vermont’s limits were the lowest in the nation.
In determining contribution limits and overall campaign finance reform, the legislature set reasonable contribution limits, supported by testimony and evidence, which uphold First Amendment rights and adhere to the Constitution.
FYI- This is another bill the governor has vetoed.
By One vote, his veto stood. We are clear Vermonter’s want clean elections with limits, so money can’t buy elections. Hence, we’ll push this legislation - and clean elections- again.
Vermont Telecommunications Authority
Because of Vermont’s small and rural population, it is difficult to get modern broadband Internet connections to every home, and equally tough getting cellular phone signals to every corner of the state. This winter, the legislature formed the Vermont Telecommunication Authority whose task will be to bring full coverage of high-speed internet service and cell phone signals within the reach of every Vermont home and business by the end of the year 2010.
The Authority will be run by a Board of Directors, and will have access to $40 million in bonding ability. It will use the money as incentives to make serving the more remote towns more attractive, and by building as many as 120 new towers on which providers can locate their transmission equipment. It will also help to construct needed fiber-optic lines to bring the signals within reach of the towers.
Working Vermonters
This year we passed legislation to assist three different groups of working Vermonters: members of the Vermont National Guard, tipped wage workers, and fire fighters.
Members of the Vermont National Guard will now be assured of 15 days leave from their regular employment for the purpose of attending guard training and drills. All permanent employees are entitled to return to their employment following call up from the Vermont National Guard. Pay and death benefits equivalent to federal guidelines are now authorized for those members of the guard who are called up on state duty. The legislature also increased tuition benefits for Vermont National Guard members attending UVM.
An estimated 4,000 Vermonters serve as tipped wage workers in our hotels, motels, and restaurants. The House has passed legislation that increases the threshold used to consider who is a “tipped worker” from the current $30 per month in tipped wages (the level established in 1957) to $120 per month. We also added a cost of living increase to the current $3.65 basic tipped employee minimum wage beginning in January 2008.
Obtaining workers’ compensation will become easier for Vermont fire fighters who contract cancer as a result of fire fighting. This benefit will be provided to fire fighters who pass an initial cancer free screening, have been non-smokers for at least 10 years, have worked for at least five years as a fire fighter, and are under the age of 65. The claim must be made within 10 years of exposure must result from certain specific cancers that have a direct link to fire fighting. The fire fighter is presumed eligible if the above conditions are present. Employers have the right to refute or contest the claim.
Workforce Training and Development Vermonters believe in education for its own inherent value, but we invest in it because it is the path to productive and meaningful jobs and careers. This year, the legislature passed important legislation that supports education and training for all Vermonters -- youth at risk, students in academic and technical education, college bound youth, and adults of all ages seeking to transition into new jobs and careers. H. 433, An Act Relating to the Next Generation Initiative of Workforce Development, provides increased grant and scholarship aid for college tuition, loan repayment in the health care field, new internship and career awareness activities for high school and college students, and job-specific training for recent graduates and adults. Vermont’s economy depends on an excellent education and training infrastructure. The legislature’s work this session created opportunities for Vermonters to prepare themselves for meaningful work and careers.
Agriculture
The centerpiece of the legislature’s work on agriculture was the Agriculture Viability Act, a bill that will help ensure the continued viability of Vermont’s agricultural industry. The primary goals of the bill are to foster the development of a diversified agricultural sector, maintain the state’s prominence as a major milk producer in the region, and ensure the continued stewardship of the land with respect for the environment. The bill contains several important provisions for Vermont agriculture, including a “buy local” system for food and dairy products purchased annually by the state and state-funded entities, and ensures that schools purchase food and dairy products grown or produced in Vermont when available. The bill also addresses the shortage of slaughter facilities by authorizing the use of mobile slaughter establishments on farms or agricultural fairgrounds and extending current law that allows farmers to slaughter, without inspection, fewer than a thousand birds for sale to individuals or at farmers’ markets, with Agency of Agriculture guidelines.
The legislature also passed a bill that establishes a procedure for organizing and funding mosquito control in the state’s three mosquito control districts in addition to boosting dairy prices.
Farm to School The Farm to School bill codifies into statute an extraordinary program that brings together the community, the classroom and the school cafeteria. It provides hands on resources such as equipment, training and materials, which enable innovative connections between local farmers, their products and local schools. It connects Vermont school children to their food source and expands their knowledge and awareness of our rural economy. H. 91 names the farm to school grants for Representative Rosemary (Rozo) McLaughlin, who died in the fall of 2006. Her desire to bring good nutrition to local schools and to help Vermont farmers expand their markets led Rozo with the able help of Rep. Mitzi Johnson to develop the concept of the farm to school and she worked tirelessly to bring these groups together to make an idea a reality. Her hard work, advocacy, and diligence make it right and fitting that we name this signature legislation for her.
House Human Services
Advance Directives Registry
The Vermont Advance Directive Registry became available on February 2, 2007. The Registry web page is online at www.healthvermont.gov/vadr and provides instructions for completing and registering advance directives.
Services for transition age youth - Provides for youth in foster care to choose to continue receiving state services (such as health care, training, special assistance) beyond the day they turn 18. The previous law “pushed them off a cliff” the day they turned 18, and for many theis lack of services pushed these youth into trouble. Next year we will look for ways to address the transition needs of youth with functional developmental disabilities and youth with severe emotional disturbances.
Helping Families Out of Poverty.
HHSC also spent considerable time rewriting our program for Helping Families Out of Poverty.
With new federal guidelines that continue to further limit the options available to help young families (usually single mothers) survive and hopefully, rise up out of poverty, we worked to find ways that meet the new more narrow federal guidelines and still provide the supports young families need to empower them and help their challenge of moving out of poverty.
We also helped move forward an effort led by Sen. Racine to comprehensively look at Childhood Poverty in Vermont.
Unfortunately, the last 5 years have seen Childhood Poverty rates in Vermont rise faster than in any other state. We hope to provide clear, accurate articulation of the problem and generate widespread support for addressing this .
VSH-We also looked at the current plans for a new State Psychiatric Hospital (VSH)to replace the old- which was declared unfit by federal regulators. We disagreed with the Governor’s plan to create a $100 Million unit at Fletcher Allen Hospital and want to look at a model that will provide services across the state, at lesser costs.
For more information on this or other legislation, please contact us and/or check out the information on the Legislature’s web site:
www.leg.state.vt.us
All bills are posted on this site along with considerable other information pertaining to your legislature.
Statehouse Reports:
Week of 4-15-07
Activity in the Vermont House seems to be nearing its peak –which I’m told is a sign that we are turning the corner and adjournment is starting to show up on the horizon. (Like the old joke about being someplace that isn’t the end of the world, but one can see it from there)
The week was filled with machinations attendant to this process and significant legislation moving forward.
The Education and Ways And Means Committees have been working hard to address the multiple concerns within education…maintaining quality, equitably paying for it, and slowing the growth of spending.
House Human Services Committee (on which I participate) presented it’s bill on reconfiguring TANF(Temporary Aid to needy families) based on new more limited federal guidelines. It’s been the paramount concern of our committee and it was ably reported out by Rep. Sandy Haas and then passed Third reading, by the House on Friday.
Interesting overview is in party structure and actions…
Republicans have been calling for increasing the role of government and undermining sound fiscal practices while Democrats have arguing for fiscal responsibility and resisting the urge to enlarge governments reach into the lives of Vermonters.
Case in point is House Appropriations reducing the size of government by cutting 9 of the Governor’s media-spinners to save $750,000 and the Republicans wanting to increase spending guidelines…e.g. The budget we currently passed increases spending by only 1(one) percent and the Republicans want to raise that by 3(three) percent.
Alongside that, the Governor seems keen on spending $100 Million dollars on a new state psychiatric hospital in Burlington...when there seem to be several other solutions that would spread those services around the state for far less money.
Things are getting curiouser and curiouser…
and so it goes (with all due respect and homage to the recently departed Kurt Vonnegut)
State House Update Week of 3-20,2007
It was not a quiet week in Lake Wobegon, and it was not a quite week at the Vermont Statehouse.
The House is shifting gears, from time spent mostly in committee researching and writing legislation-to spending more time on the floor, debating and ,hopefully, passing bills to help V ermonters.
The most widely watched debate and vote came on Wednesday with H.44-Patient Choice at End of Life. The debate on this bill went on for app. Four hours. The debate culminated in a vote which defeated the bill 62-82.
I supported this bill and still support the concepts of choice, better end of life care with palliative and hospice care.
The Terry Schiavo Case certainly showed that CHOICE is NOT respected by some in the political arena and I believe it is essential that CHOICE be respected by those who would otherwise have government impose their beliefs with intrusions into our bedrooms, doctors offices and hospital rooms.
As the week went on, we also were presented with several other significant bills which included the Agriculture Sustainability Act, the yearly Transportation bill and the Commerce Committee’s Next generation bill. This bill provides supports and incentives to help provide young Vermonters with what they need to empower themselves into becoming vibrant, vital young adults. Key to this bill s at least $4 Million in scholarship and training programs for young Vermonters-contrary to the Governor’s assertions that the legislature isn’t furnishing these opportunities for young Vermonters. The bill’s intent is to help with the present and encourage these young people to utilize these skills and build their lives in Vermont.
House Human Service’s Committee we are hoping to pass out of the House a bill to provide supports for transitional youth beyond their 18th birthday.
We are also looking to pass out TANF restructuring bill. Temporary Aid to Needy Families -TANF, is meant to help families out of poverty. However, the new regulations precipitating the need for this bill are in reality a continued attack by the Bush administration on women and children in this country. The continued restriction on how states can help makes it increasingly difficult to provide meaningful help. Despite- or because of this, we need to worm harder to help those vulnerable Vermonters who are trying to better their lives and the lives of their young children.
March 5,2007 Town Meeting Week
As we head back to our respective homes and districts for Town Meeting break, the legislature has laid the groundwork for finishing work on a number of significant pieces of legislation.
From my perspective on the House Human Services Committee, we completed a deeply moving week of concentrated work on H.44- A Bill on Patient Choice and Control at End of Life.
(to read a copy of the whole bill, visit the Legislature' websitewww.leg.state.vt.us)
With much heartfelt testimony from both sides of this issue, the committee voted the bill out of committee by a 7-4 vote. The bill goes next to House Judiciary and ,if passed, to the full House....then Senate and on the the Governor.
Among the highlights of the opening two months of this bienium are the Emergency Dairy Aid Bill, the House Resoultion Urging An Orderly and Immediate Withdrawal of US Troops from Iraq- and personally, having my first Joint Resolution passed, HCR 33-Celebrating Vermont's Public School Students and Educators.
(The text of which is included on this page)
Looking ahead, we have much work to do in protecting Vermont's environment, continuing to build a new healthcare future for all Vermonters, providing for our future energy needs, maintaining our educational excellence while continuing to provide needs-based relief to those struggling to pay their property taxes.And, in Human Services Committee -looking to serve our most vulnerable Vermonters, from the very young to the very old,and all those who are unable to take care of themselves.
State of Vermont
House of Representatives
Montpelier, Vermont
Concurrent House Resolution
H.C.R. 33
House concurrent resolution honoring the many achievements of Vermont’s elementary and secondary public school students and teachers
Offered by: Representatives Mrowicki of Putney, Andrews of Rutland City, Aswad of Burlington, Atkins of Winooski, Botzow of Pownal, Brooks of Montpelier, Chen of Mendon, Clarkson of Woodstock, Clerkin of Hartford, Consejo of Sheldon, Copeland-Hanzas of Bradford, Courcelle of Rutland City, Davis of Washington, Deen of Westminster, Edwards of Brattleboro, Emmons of Springfield, Evans of Essex, Fisher of Lincoln, Fitzgerald of St. Albans City, Frank of Underhill, French of Randolph, Gilbert of Fairfax, Godin of Milton, Haas of Rochester, Head of S. Burlington, Heath of Westford, Hosford of Waitsfield, Jerman of Essex, Jewett of Ripton, Johnson of South Hero, Kitzmiller of Montpelier, Lenes of Shelburne, Leriche of Hardwick, Lippert of Hinesburg, Lorber of Burlington, Maier of Middlebury, Malcolm of Pawlet, Manwaring of Wilmington, Marek of Newfane, Martin of Wolcott, Milkey of Brattleboro, Miller of Shaftsbury, Minter of Waterbury, Mook of Bennington, Moran of Wardsboro, Nease of Johnson, Nuovo of Middlebury, Obuchowski of Rockingham, Ojibway of Hartford, Orr of Charlotte, Partridge of Windham, Pearson of Burlington, Pellett of Chester, Peltz of Woodbury, Pillsbury of Brattleboro, Potter of Clarendon, Pugh of S. Burlington, Stevens of Shoreham, Symington of Jericho, Trombley of Grand Isle, Zenie of Colchester and Zuckerman of Burlington
Whereas, elementary and secondary public educators and students in Vermont can take great pride in their recent accomplishments, and
Whereas, the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) ranked Vermont second nationally in the organization’s evaluation of states’ public schools’ academic accomplishments, and
Whereas, for the second consecutive year, Vermont was listed second in Morgan Quinto Press’s “Smartest State” educational rankings, and
Whereas, the respected publication Education Week determined that Vermont schools performed third best in the nation in achievement and achievement gains, and
Whereas, Vermont, New Hampshire, and Rhode Island have developed a common educational assessment program, and Vermont youngsters were ranked first in proficiency in every subject, and
Whereas, the state’s developmental reading assessment showed that in 2006, 85 percent of Vermont’s second graders were meeting or exceeding the reading standard, which is a marked improvement over a comparable figure of 73 percent who met this benchmark in 1979, and
Whereas, nationally, Vermont ranks seventh in weighted SAT scoring achievement, and the state’s secondary school students score six percent higher than the national mean on AP examinations, and
Whereas, 92 percent of Vermont’s public school teachers who have worked in core academic subjects have earned the “highly qualified” teacher designation from the United States Department of Education, and
Whereas, nearly 70 percent of public school employees in Vermont are educators or instructors, which is far above the national average of 62.2 percent, and
Whereas, in the realm of arts and music, three Vermont schools have won the Kennedy Center Alliance for Arts Education National School of Distinction awards since 2001, and additional schools have won similar recognition on the state level, while, since 2000, 13 youngsters have been awarded full scholarships to study at the National Symphony Orchestra Summer Institute, and
Whereas, Vermonters have reason to be proud of the state’s public school students and the teachers who work so patiently and creatively to enable these youngsters to achieve these impressive results, now therefore be it
Resolved by the House of Representatives:
That the General Assembly honors the many achievements of Vermont’s elementary and secondary public school students and teachers, and be it further
Resolved: That the secretary of state be directed to send a copy of this resolution to Commissioner of Education Richard Cate, the Vermont School Boards Association, the Vermont Superintendents Association, the Vermont Principals’ Association, the Vermont NEA, and the Vermont Alliance for Arts Education.